Tuesday, November 6, 2007

The Dog Days of Contrarian Investing


In his soon to be published quarterly report, legendary value investor, Bill Miller, makes the following observations:

“This market has been remarkably serially correlated. In plain talk, what has gone up keeps going up, and what has not, does not. Valuation has not mattered at all. What has mattered is price momentum. This is very similar to what we saw with tech, telecom, and internet names in 1999. It is not yet that extreme, but it is pretty extreme.

The best quintile of stocks based on traditional valuation factors such as price to earnings, price to book, price to sales, and dividend yield, has underperformed the market by over 1000 basis points this year. The best quintile on price momentum alone, using 3 and 9 month price trends, has outperformed by 1400 basis points.”

Mr. Miller’s comments highlight several points that have been repeatedly raised on this blog and in my reports – namely the highly correlated nature of the equity markets. Two questions are related to this point: Why are markets so highly correlated and how should an investor exploit the situation?

As noted many times before, the highly correlated nature of the equity markets is due in large part to the enormous sums of actively-traded money that is in the hands of the hedge fund and other momentum lemmings. Bereft of original ideas, many hedge fund managers have little recourse than to chase the trades that ensure their relative performance record does not fall so far behind their counterparts (code for keeping my house in Greenwich).

Naturally, it should be assumed that these very same hedge fund managers believe that they have systems and investment strategies designed to gain alpha. At least that’s what the marketing material says. The sad fact is, however, the results are just not there. Since the proliferation of hedge funds, the performance results has regressed to the mean, so much so that there is little to no difference between the on average underperforming hedge fund manager and the on average underperforming mutual fund manager. (The only real difference is the compensation scheme.)

Moreover, logic dictates that there are only so many truly original strategies thereby limiting the arbitrage and other alpha generating strategies available. Put another way, how many brilliant 20-something money managers can there be? Hence, lemming-like momentum investing.

If this be the case, how does an investor exploit the situation?

Investment Strategy Implications

There is every reason to believe that hedge fund managers pressured to justify their high fees will be even doubly pressured these last two months to produce as much alpha as conceivably possible. Therefore, if price momentum investing is the dominant approach taken by many such market players, the odds are that, from now until December 31st, what has worked will continue to work meaning that bottom fishing and contrarian plays will likely underperform and the winners of 2007 will remain so, if not accelerate until the books close for the year.

The momentum game is here to stay. At least through the end of this year and likely into the early part of next year. Contrarian strategies, like the kind that Bill Miller advocates, will likely remain the least attractive approach to investing for some time.

No doubt, the day will come when being a contrarian will pay. However, for the reasons stated above (and others noted in prior blog posting and reports), I don’t believe that day is today.

Actionable steps: For predominantly US investors stay overweight the weak US dollar and global growth story of Info Tech, Industrials, Energy, Gold, and Large Cap Growth. Stay underweight the US consumer related themes of Financials and Consumer Discretionary. For global players sell China into strength, stay long Europe large and mega cap (Europe 350 – IEV) and a proportionally balanced mix of emerging market issues.

Specific investment recommendations can be found in the Model Growth Portfolio (MGP), which is available only to subscribers. MGP performance results are noted on the upper left portion of this blog.

Monday, November 5, 2007

Living with Angst. Exploiting the Fear.


excerpts from this week's report:
"Halloween may have passed but when it comes to credit derivatives and the like it is the tricks and not the treats that keep on coming for investors.


The black hole that is credit derivatives continues to haunt the slowly awakened investor masses. And there remains much in the murkiness of the less-than-full disclosure world of the hundreds of trillions of dollars of leverage upon leverage debt. Moreover, collateralization and securitization combined with leverage upon leverage ensures that more shoes will likely drop before we are safely out of the woods. As noted many months ago, “it is unwise bordering on imprudent to assume that terrible will not follow bad.”

So, why am I recommending that investors not only hold onto their positions but begin to step back into the market and selectively add to key positions? In a phrase, it ain’t over ‘til it’s over.

The positive offsets to all this credit-derived pain are threefold:..."

"Model Growth Portfolio Results

What a week!

Thanks to the underweight in Financials and Consumer Discretionary along with the Gold, the MGP produced one of its best all-time weekly relative performance results of 63 basis points and, in the process, has pushed up the year to date alpha to 223 basis points (see report)..."

also in this week's report:

* Valuation Model
* Model Growth Portfolio
* Investor Sentiment Data
* Chart Focus: Productivity and Unit Labor Costs
* Sectors and Styles Market Monitor
* Key Economic Indicators

To gain access to this and all reports, click on the subscription info link to your left.

Friday, November 2, 2007

Quotable Quotes: Bad Habits


The disappointment the market demonstrates at the prospect of no new rate cuts (to the exclusion of other factors) implies some bad habits have formed. Therefore, a few sage words on the addictive nature of bad habits.



“Chains of habit are too light to be felt until they are too heavy to be broken.”
Warren Buffet

“Habit is a cable; we weave a thread each day, and at last we cannot break it.”
Horace Mann

“Just cause you got the monkey off your back doesn't mean the circus has left town.”
George Carlin

“Little minds mistake little objects for great ones, and lavish away upon the former that time and attention which only the latter deserve. The strong mind distinguishes, not only between the useful and the useless, but likewise between the useful and the curious.”
Philip Dormer Stanhope, 4th Earl Chesterfield

Have a good weekend.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Technical Thursdays: The Dirtier the Dollar, The More Gold Shines









Blog entry from July 12th: “Forget Goldlilocks, Think Gold”
Blog entry from April 24th: “Gold: The $1,000 Investment”*

The first chart** shows the performance of the yellow metal versus S&P 500 since July 12th. No question about that call.
The second** is the price performance of Gold since the Gold tracker began trading. So far, so very good.

However, being right is always yesterday’s news. What about now? Is $1,000 achievable? In a word: youbetcha.

A few follow up thoughts:

Since my March 2005 report on Gold, the central argument for Gold has been the US dollar and its diminishing role of the world’s reserve currency. That view not only remains unchanged but is actually accelerating. The debasing of the American currency (via the Fed and its propensity to run the printing press to avoid even the slightest real economic pain) coupled with the strong growth in foreign reserves is driving many holders of dollar denominated assets (US Treasuries, in particular) to think twice (three times, four times?) about adding to a losing position. Yesterday’s ¼ point rate cut, the Fed's second best decision, contributes to the situation.

To leave the Fed funds rate unchanged was the better choice. However, the Fed's intentions are clear - rates are headed lower. And no matter how you slice it, lower US rates only reinforce the downtrend in the dollar. So, while the dollar may be poised for a crowded trade, short covering rally, the mega and cyclical trend is unmistakable: Down and dirty. And the dirtier the dollar gets, the less inclined foreign buyers will be to own more of a poor performing asset and more inclined to diversify their holdings. Witness the rise in sovereign wealth funds. Witness the rise in the Euro. Witness the rise in Gold.

Investment Strategy Implications

The slow, steady crash in the dollar threatens to get out of hand. Heaven help us if it does. And while no one knows what level a relatively non-productive asset like Gold should trade, it is without question that Gold is benefiting from the diversification effects of major buyers of dollar denominated assets.

Conclusion: Up to a 5% position in Gold belongs in everyone’s portfolio for the foreseeable future.

*Scroll down to "Topics Discussed" links to your left to view.
**click on images to enlarge.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Whose Fed Is It Anyway?

The 180 the Fed sprung on everyone last month needs to be rectified and clarified with today’s rate decision and subsequent minutes by sending a clear and convincing signal that this Fed and not Wall Street’s bankers is calling the shots based on the needs of the economy and not the needs of bankers who made poor business decisions. The key word in the previous sentence is convincing for everyone knows what were the stated reasons for last month’s reversal. However, as with the claims of Patriots coach Belichick that they are not running up the score, the rhetoric doesn’t seem to match the actions.


Investment Strategy Implications

History demonstrates that rate cuts result in increased asset values. In the multi decade, mega trend of the Debt Supercycle (see prior commentaries) with the tipping point of too much debt still in the future plus the powerfully positive effects of globalization, the productivity and growth benefits from advances in information and communications technologies, and the embracing of market economies in nearly all segments of the world, rate cuts will produce higher asset values.

Moreover, given realistic expectations that a US slowdown will result in only a modest decline in global growth, a sustained decline in the cost of capital is yet another reason why rate cuts will result in higher asset values in such an environment. The risks are, however, on both the inflationary and central bank credibility side.

With global growth as strong as it is, high levels of liquidity, high levels of growth of liquidity (see previous comments re MZM), strong balance sheets (corporate and nation states), and reasonable valuations the investment strategy decision comes down to the expansion and contraction of the asset allocation mix (cyclical/tactical calls) and the sector and style picks for what increasingly looks like an emerging inflationary global environment.

Improvisation may work well on the entertainment stage. But in the high stakes game of global finance and the world economy, the risks of sending the wrong message via a decision process that is confused, if not conflicted, are great. Knowing whose Fed it is would help.

Have a fun Halloween.

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

The Year End Rally in Waiting


Now that we are well into the current earnings season several earnings trends are matching recent stock performance, most notably the polar ends of the performance scale - Financials and Tech. As the table* to your left shows, however, the overall earnings picture ex Financials is about in line with expectations - low single digit growth.


Investment Strategy Implications

Once tomorrow's Fed rate decision is behind us, the year end price action for equities will depend in part on the answers to three key questions:

• Will the US economy experience a soft or hard landing?
• Has the global economy decoupled from the US to a sufficient degree that will enable global growth to remain robust?
• How far along are we in the black hole of credit derivatives discovery process?

Notwithstanding all the issues that threaten to derail the aging bull, with liquidity so abundant, corporate and nation state finances in excellent shape, valuation levels reasonable, and technicals in compliance, should all three questions be answered in the affirmative the odds for a decent if not strong end of year rally are high.

*Click image to enlarge.
Source: Wall Street Journal

Monday, October 29, 2007

Surfing the Liquidity Wave

excerpts from this week's report:

"Summer may have ended but not so for the liquidity boys. The boards remain well waxed and the investment/trading surfers continue to seek the perfect wave.


With MZM growth now averaging 20% (see report)..."

Investment Strategy Implications

"The global macro crisis in progress will lead to a day of reckoning but that day has been forestalled time and again thanks to the bounty of liquidity and easy money. Hedge funds and private equity have not witnessed a reduction in their collective $2.5 trillion. And that money, like the excess liquidity the Fed has pumped into the real economy, has to go somewhere. Where that capital is deployed should be the focus of equity investors regardless of their justifiable concerns over a debasing US dollar and emerging market bubbles.

Until such time when the technical indicators warn of a mega trend change, financial assets that are not tainted with..."

also in this week's report:

* Valuation Model
* Model Growth Portfolio
* Investor Sentiment Data
* Chart Focus: Dollar versus Euro - The Crowded Trade Rally
* Sectors and Styles Market Monitor
* Key Economic Indicators

To gain access to this and all reports, click on the subscription info link to your left.

Friday, October 26, 2007

Quotable Quotes: Ben Graham


While preparing for the fall Equity Analysis classes that I teach for NYSSA, I came across this priceless quote from Ben Graham. Most fitting in the current age of financial wizardry.



"In a manuscript from 1936 (reprinted in Ellis 1991), Benjamin Graham pictures the chair of a major coproation outlining how his company will return to profitability in the middle of the Great Depression of the 20th Century:

"Contrary to expectations, no changes will be made in the company's manufacturing or selling policies. Instead, the bookkeeping system is to be entirely revamped. By adopting and further improving a number of modern accounting and financial devices the corporation's earning power will be amazingly transformed."

The top item on the chair's list gives a flavor of the progress that will be made: "Accordingly, the Board has decided to extend the write-down policy initiated in the 1935 report, and to mark down the Fixed Assets from $1,338,552,858.96 to a round Minus $1,000,000,000...As plant wears out, the liability becomes correspondingly reduced. Hence, instead of the present depreciation charge of some $47,000,000 yearly there will be an annual appreciation credit of 5 percent, or $50,000,000. This will increase earnings by no less than $97,000,000 per annum." Summing up, the chair shares the foresight of the Board: "...The Board is not unmindful of the possibility that some of our competitors may seek to offset our new advantages by adopting similar accounting improvements...Should necessity arise, moreover, we believe we shall be able to maintain our deserved superiority by introducing still more advanced bookkeeping methods, which are even now under development in our Experimental Accounting Laboratory."

"Equity Asset Valuation"
Stowe, Robinson, Pinto, and McLeavey

The more things change, the more they remain the same. Simply substitute credit derivatives for manufacturing and asset values for depreciation and viola!

Have a good weekend.

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Technical Thursdays: Playing to Win

What September giveth October taketh away.

The October takeaway of September’s Fed rate cut inspired gift is right on schedule. FUD (fear, uncertainty, and doubt) has returned and angst is on the rise again. No surprise from this strategist’s perspective.

As noted at the start of both September (see “September Swoon? Not Likely”) and October (Boo!) the commentary on this blog and in my reports forecast a market that would be a net zero by the time Halloween came and went (see prior blog postings). And while only a crazy man would try to be so cute in timing each wiggle and swiggle of a highly dynamic economic and market environment, sometimes conditions line up just right where making such a call is worth the risk. Playing to win trumps playing not to lose.

The fundamental argument for the net zero view centers on the unresolved credit problems that were first considered dealt with when the Fed cut the discount rate as the momentum lemmings put their mountain of capital to work. A little premature and quite a bit simplistic, to say the least.

The unresolved credit derivative’s risk factor is counterbalanced by the positive effects of high degrees of liquidity (aided further by the Fed’s dubious rate cut), very strong balance sheets (corporate and government), and strong global growth, among others that have been noted on this blog and in prior reports time and again.

One technical argument (among others) for a flat September/October time period is illustrated in the above chart on the S&P 500. Applying my long term price action indicator, the moving averages principle*, to the current price action of the S&P 500 it is plain to see that no violation of three elements of the principle – price relative to moving averages, 50 day relative to 200 day, and the slope of both moving averages – has occurred. Therefore, until all three conditions are met, the established trend must be assumed to be the mega trend in force. Which is another way of saying it’s a bull market ‘til it ain’t. And ain’t happens when a major market top is formed, part of which involves the aforementioned moving averages principle.

Investment Strategy Implications

From a technical perspective, the current October correction of September’s rate cut mini euphoria suggests a move to the 200 day moving average, which is right around 1470. Given the strong downward move in MACD, should the S&P 500 reach 1470, it will probably have to trade around that level for a short while thereby repairing the technical damage that all corrections produce before any November/December year end rally can get underway. My estimate is < 2 weeks. Then it’s off to the year end races.

*See prior Technical Thursdays entries for more info on the moving averages principle.

To view a larger version of the charts, click on the image.

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

The Hidden Value in Valuation Models: The Message of Mr. Market



"I think therefore I predict."



This is the motto of all investment strategists. And rightly so for what other purpose does an investment strategist serve than to analyze then predict? There is, however (you knew there was an however coming), a complementary role that an investment strategist serves which is to assess the valuation calls made by Mr. Market expressed in the form of an expected return. Accordingly, using the simple yet very effective Modified Fed Model above (click on table for larger image) we can explore some of the predictive elements of Mr. Market.

As of yesterday’s close, the inputs for equities (S&P 500) and interest rates (10 year US Treasury) are 1520 and 4.41%. Operating earnings estimates for the S&P 500 for 2007 are right around $92. Now, if operating earnings for S&P 500 for 2007 come in around $92, full value for the S&P 500 is somewhere between around 1700 and 1766. That interprets into a 12 to 16% gain from current levels. Not bad for just over 2 months! However, as tantalizing as an average of 14% for 2 months (84% annualized) might be, it is more reasonable to assume that Mr. Market has some other time frame and set of inputs in mind.

Let’s say Mr. Market is a good student of market history. Therefore, he is looking beyond the next 2 months and well into 2008. Perhaps he is looking as far ahead as the next twelve months, give or take. Under those circumstances, Mr. Market seems to be gravitating more toward a more traditional annual rate of return, something closer to the long-term return on large cap equities of 12%.

In that case, to produce a 12% return Mr. Market seems to be calling for one of several scenarios to unfold. In one assumption, rates and operating earnings rise by ½ % and 4.3%, respectively. In another, rates remain unchanged while earnings slump 4.3% from $92 to $88*. (Both are highlighted in the boxed areas of the yellow shaded zone.) Or perhaps both rates and earnings remain unchanged (boxed returns noted above).

Investment Strategy Implications

The question an investor needs to answer is “What are the probabilities of certain earnings and interest rate scenarios given specific inputs?”

All investment strategists have their views. We pontificate on them with great regularity. Nevertheless, it is incumbent upon every investment strategist and investor to attempt to understand just what Mr. Market is saying in the form of scenarios based on rates of return, be it this valuation model or some other that has a comparable track record.

At present, Mr. Market is in a fairly narrow zone of probable outcomes. That will no doubt change as the multi faceted aspects of the valuation inputs evolve over the coming months and year ahead. Then again there is the possibility that Mr. Market is way off the mark and rates and/or earnings move dramatically away from the narrow zone currently forecasted.

Getting that call right generates the alpha all investors fervently desire, something Mr. Market just cannot help provide. What's your call?

*Of course, a third option exists – the model is all wrong. The inputs are too high, too low, or just plain irrelevant. While this may be the case, the fact that the inputs and the adjustments made (raising the capitalization factor, the 10 year Treasure rate, by 80 to 100 basis points) are derived from actual experience over the life of the current bull market suggests that there is some validity in its methodology.